When I published “Too Symbolic to Fail” on November 11, the Council’s Planning and Economic Development committee had not yet met. The essay said the committee would decide on November 12 whether to recommend the $548 million incentives request and the $133.3 million benefits package. It has now decided, and the decision says a good deal about how settled this deal really is.

The committee did not recommend it. At its November 12 meeting, it sent the incentives and the benefits package to the full Council without a recommendation. The vote split two to one: the chair, Latisha Johnson, and Coleman Young II voted to move it forward; Gabriela Santiago-Romero voted no. Johnson said she would like to see adjustments to the proposed incentives, and that if the full Council is not satisfied, the plan can come back to her committee.

A referral without a recommendation is a committee declining to vouch for what it sends on. That matters here, because the committee had in front of it the questions this essay asked. On November 6 the full Council sent it four memos on the project from two of its members, which ask, among other things, for a legal review of the nonprofit ownership structure and of whether the benefits commitments can be enforced. Its November 12 agenda also listed Council members’ memos asking whether community requests such as revenue sharing are feasible, and a confidential memo from the City’s Law Department on revenue sharing and community ownership. Nothing in the news accounts of the hearing says those questions were answered. As far as the public record shows, the basic terms of the new owner are still unwritten: who holds the land, who receives the surplus, who appoints the board, and what returns to the public if the nonprofit fails.

The calendar is now short. The full Council could take up the package as soon as Tuesday, November 17, though Johnson said she did not expect the conversations to be finished by then. The developers want approval before Thanksgiving. After the Council, the Michigan Strategic Fund decides last.

None of this changes the argument; it sharpens it. I do not argue that the project should die. I argue that the Council should not spend the public’s only leverage, its vote, before the public’s terms exist in writing. The committee has now said, in the only way a committee can, that it is not ready to vouch for the deal. The full Council should hold to the same standard: ask for the owner’s terms on paper, read them, and then vote. A week costs the project very little. Thirty years of terms, once the vote is cast, cost the public a great deal more.

The original essay stands as published, and you can read it in full here: Too Symbolic to Fail.

Sources